• home
  • bourbon
  • links
  • blog
  • bio
  • contact form
               donstacy.com

Evidence-Based Medicine

6/19/2012

 
Arthur Caplan is a well-respected bioethicist from the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania.  His opinions are typical of "mainstream" bioethics ideology.  A May 20, 2011 article he penned for the Journal of Clinical Oncology, "Will Evidence Ever Be Sufficient to Resolve the Challenge of Cost Containment?," prompted this LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG post.

The first nugget to be mined from Caplan's article is his admission that evidence-based medicine is not, as the statists argue, a rationalist philosophy of utilizing objective scientific data to inform medical decision making.  Instead, evidence-based medicine is a statist "tool for reigning in the escalating costs of cancer diagnosis and treatment."  No shit, Artie.

The second nugget is Caplan's smackdown of statists who assert that "cost containment requires nothing more than a long hard look at the evidence to forge consensus about what to cover."  He cites two examples (the 2010 US Preventive Services Task Force recommendation against routine screening mammograms for women > 40 years old and the 2010 Medicare decision to pay for the Provenge advanced prostate cancer vaccine), which he states are scenarios in which "evidence regarding cancer has yielded to politics, money, and emotion."  Memo to Artie: you are not the first person to recognize the subjective nature of value.

The third nugget is Caplan's attempt to rehabilitate the concept of evidence-based medicine (an ideology he mocked in earlier paragraphs) by proposing 4 "shifts in thinking about the ethics of health care" that must be adopted so his statist pals can more easily ration health care.  SHIFT #1: statists must recognize the subjective nature of value.  LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG RETORT #1: no chance Artie because statists refuse to accept the existence of objective economic truth.  SHIFT #2: doctors must begin to offer "an opinion informed by evidence" rather than merely "offer all possible options to the patient ... ."  LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG RETORT #2: clearly this is news to you Artie but high-quality physicians, such as me, commonly describe multiple options to the patient AND ALSO deliver a recommendation for one of the options based on the available evidence (phase 3 studies, phase 2 studies, phase 1 studies, retrospective reviews, case-control studies, anecdotal data otherwise known as personal experience, etc.).  SHIFT #3: doctors must jettison the old-fashioned notion that their job is to act as advocates for the "personal best interest" of individual patients and instead adopt the modern notion that "a good and virtuous doctor must make recommendations about care as an advocate for the patient, as an honest source of evidence, and as a steward of society's medical resources."  LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG RETORT #3: like his pals Artie is an evil statist asshole.  SHIFT #4: pragmatically rich people should get access to experimental treatments first.  LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG RETORT #4: also true Artie but your statist pals will never ever under any circumstance permit the existence of a free or freed market in health care.

Per usual, please peruse Caplan's article.  I make this as a medical recommendation.  Even the ancients knew laughter is the best medicine.       

Comments are closed.

    LIBERTARIAN BIOETHICS BLOG

    Author

    Don Stacy is a 47 yo libertarian writer and physician.  His articles have been published by multiple libertarian-themed websites.  He practices medicine as a radiation oncologist in Hazard, KY.     

    Archives

    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010

    Categories

    All
    4 Fundamental Principles
    4 Step Heathcare Solution
    Abigail Alliance
    Abraham Lincoln
    Afterbirth Abortion
    Afterbirth Abortion 2
    Ama Bioethics Principles
    Amnesty International
    Animal Rights
    Animal Rights 2
    Banning A Risky Product
    Beneficence
    Bioethics Consults
    Blog Name
    Blog Plan
    Brain-Dead Bioethics
    Brain Dead Bioethics 2
    British Health Care
    Cancer Drugs
    C.I.A. Doctors
    Circumcision
    Classical-Liberal Bioethics
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 2
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 3
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 4
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 5
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 6
    Classical Liberal Bioethics 7
    Clinical Trials Reporting
    Clinical Trials Reporting 2
    Code Of Federal Regs
    Contractarianism
    Cooperative Groups
    Economics Of Healthcare
    Economics Of Healthcare 2
    Engelhardt And Children
    Engelhardt And Children 2
    Euthanasia
    Evidence-Based Medicine
    Facebook Ethics
    Genetic Results Return
    Genetic Results Return 2
    Guatemala S.T.D. Study
    Influenza Vaccination
    Inst. Review Boards
    Inst. Review Boards 2
    Inst. Review Boards 3
    Inst. Review Boards 4
    Inst. Review Boards 5
    Justice
    Just Price
    Kidney Sellers
    Kidney Sellers 10
    Kidney Sellers 11
    Kidney Sellers 12
    Kidney Sellers 13
    Kidney Sellers 14
    Kidney Sellers 15
    Kidney Sellers 2
    Kidney Sellers 3
    Kidney Sellers 4
    Kidney Sellers 5
    Kidney Sellers 6
    Kidney Sellers 7
    Kidney Sellers 8
    Kidney Sellers 9
    Liberation Biology
    Liberation Biology 2
    Liberation Biology 3
    Liberation Biology 4
    Liberation Biology 5
    Liberation Biology 6
    Liberation Biology 7
    Liberation Biology 8
    Liberation Biology 9
    Libertarian Bioethics
    Libertarian Premises
    Libertarian Premises 2
    Liberty Bioeth And Relig
    Liberty Bioeth And Relig 2
    Liberty Encyclopedia
    Liberty Encyclopedia 2
    Liberty Engelhardt Crit.
    Liberty Engelhardt Crit. 2
    Lives At Risk
    Lives At Risk 2
    Lives At Risk 3
    Lives At Risk 4
    Lives At Risk 5
    Lives At Risk 6
    Lives At Risk 7
    Lives At Risk 8
    Lives At Risk 9
    Mandatory Research Biopsies
    Money May Matter
    National Cancer Institute
    National Cancer Institute 2
    Neuroethics
    Nonmaleficence
    Organ Donation
    P.G.D.
    Phys. For Human Rights 1
    Phys. For Human Rights 2
    Political Triage
    Principles For Allocation
    Principles Of Bioethics
    Principles Of Bioethics 10
    Principles Of Bioethics 2
    Principles Of Bioethics 3
    Principles Of Bioethics 4
    Principles Of Bioethics 5
    Principles Of Bioethics 6
    Principles Of Bioethics 7
    Principles Of Bioethics 8
    Principles Of Bioethics 9
    Rationing Cancer Care
    Respect For Autonomy
    RTOG & NSABP
    Secrecy And Radiation
    Showing That You Care
    Sigrid Fry-Revere
    Skid Row
    Soviet Medicine
    Soviet Medicine 2
    Test
    The Carriage-Trade Trend
    The Chemist's War
    The Expanding Circle
    The Expanding Circle 2
    The Expanding Circle 3
    The Expanding Circle 4
    The Expanding Circle 5
    The Expanding Circle 6
    The Expanding Circle 7
    The Expanding Circle 8
    The Expanding Circle 9
    The Nathaniel Centre
    Tuskegee Syphilis Study
    U.N.E.S.C.O.
    U.S. Human Experiments
    U.S. Medical Experiments
    Warning Labels
    What It Feels Like
    What It Feels Like 2
    What It Feels Like 3
    Why Health Is Not Special

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    ANARCHO-CAPITALIST FLAG
Web Hosting by IPOWER